send to a friend | print | comment
Five Democrats who could shake up the Governor’s race
For months, Democratic insiders have looked at their party’s field for Governor and asked: “Is this it?”
And that was before Lehigh County Executive Don Cunningham stepped aside. The candidates that remain are perceived front-runner Dan Onorato, the Allegheny County Executive, state Auditor General Jack Wagner and Philadelphia businessman Tom Knox. While those candidates would surely wave off such a perception, there’s no denying that people on both sides of the aisle consider the Democratic field, at the moment, to be relatively weak.
“There’s got to be someone else who’s going to come up, right?” one Democratic consultant not involved in the race asked pa2010.com recently.
With that in mind, we offer up a list of the five Democrats who could potentially turn next year’s primary upside down. An important caution: There’s little if any reason to believe that any of these folks would even consider making a run for the Governor’s Mansion.
But in the world where political blood sport equals priceless entertainment… we can hope.
5. Josh Shapiro
Probably the least likely on our list to even think of such a move right now, the Montgomery County state Representative is known to have ambitions for higher office and was stymied in his attempts to run for Senate when Arlen Specter switched parties. He’s being encouraged to run for Lieutenant Governor. But when you’re young, handsome and a tireless campaigner, why settle for second fiddle? Still, as he works to avoid alienating his fellow lawmakers during a contentious budget season, a run at the Governor’s Mansion is almost certainly the last thing on his mind.
4. Chris Doherty
The Scranton Mayor is emerging as a political powerhouse from a major population center that is increasingly important to winning statewide elections. He’s flying high after winning the Democratic nomination for reelection while, in a rare and fascinating quirk, also winning the Republican nomination as a write-in. Yes, that means his name will be on both sides of the ballot this November. He’s also thinking of a run for Lt. Gov. But like we said above, why settle?
3. Joe Sestak
That’s right, the same Delaware County Congressman who won’t stop talking about his all-but-definite “intention to run against” Senator Arlen Specter next year. In spite of all the noise he’s made, some people still just can’t seem to believe he’s going to run against Specter and the entire Democratic establishment. In the meantime, a statewide media blitz is likely to do wonders for his name recognition. Maybe he’d like to be Governor instead?
2. Allyson Schwartz
The Montgomery County Congresswoman might do more than anyone on this list to completely change the dynamic of the Governor’s race if she wanted to. Yes, she’d be the only woman running from either party. But she would also bring a different, lower-key, down-to-business style than some of the other candidates we’ve named. She’s holed up in Washington trying to help push health care reform through Congress, so until that happens, don’t expect any political movement from her. But hey, it could happen, right?
And the No. 1 Democrat who could shake up the Governor’s race is… Bob Casey
The first-term Senator, former gubernatorial candidate and son-of-a-governor is the big kahuna on this list, the man who could throw all our assumptions about the race out the window. Though he lost the primary to Ed Rendell in 2002, his credentials as a conservative Democrat remain ideal for a state still coming to terms with its increasingly liberal identity. As a close ally to President Obama, he could have more help from the White House than one might think. He’s sitting in a Senate seat that’s probably his for as long as he wants it. But the beautiful part? As a Senator not on the ballot in 2010, he wouldn’t even have to give that up to make another run at the Mansion.
So now it’s all out there. Any takers?
July 8, 2009 at 2:14 pm
Tags: Allyson Schwartz, Bob Casey, Chris Doherty, Dan Onorato, Jack Wagner, Joe Sestak, Josh Shapiro, Tom Knox









phillypride
Jul 8th, 2009
Heard from a good source that Doherty is running for governor.
How good was source?
Doherty asked (him/her) to run campaign.
anonymous
Jul 8th, 2009
Last time I checked, Onorato has raised more money than all of the other Democrats and Republicans in the race — combined. Add to that a great record on ecomomic issues, and being from the West, he sounds like a very strong candidate to me.
anonymous
Jul 8th, 2009
This post is senseless babble. Onorato is the strongest candidate on either side. Dan, you need to expand your circle beyond the same cynical consultants. There’s a reason none of the candidates in the race hired them.
joepilch
Jul 8th, 2009
Dan the tax man??? Corbett will cruise past him in a general if Onorato can get through the primary. Dan Onorato 2009= Bob Casey 2001…ask Bob how his guv campaign turned out.
GOPhawk
Jul 8th, 2009
Dan, this post is useless nonsense. You know who else could run? You. So jump in.
joepilch
Jul 8th, 2009
This post is exactly the sort of stuff that I enjoy reading on this site…thought provoking & speculative…that’s why we’re on this site to begin with!
Naysayers in this thread are just Onorato ditto-heads.
By the way, my comparison of Onorato to Casey was foolish in retrospect. Onorato is in a MUCH weaker position, being that he has weak name recognition and a history of raising taxes.
I may be overthinking this one, but I really think for the Dems to knock off a very strong candidate in Corbett they need to nominate an outside-the-box type choice, like Scranton’s Chris Doherty or maybe one of the other guys mentioned above. People are vastly overestimating Onorato’s appeal.
Grand Old Party Foul
Jul 8th, 2009
Here’s where your comparison is off. Onorato isn’t Bob Casey ‘01 because there is no Rendell in this field. If anything, Onorato is to 2010 what Rendell was to ‘02 — the big city guy with a good record who can raise money and shake things up.
Anonymous
Jul 8th, 2009
How is a political insider going to shake things up? don’t you need an outsider, a non-politician to shake things up?
Anonymous
Jul 8th, 2009
Good record? A big hole in the ground, overbudget taxpayer rip-off from his Port Authority where the tax dollars go to his contributors? And now his PA wants to raise fares. This Onorato is a typical corporatist Democrat — tax the workers and hobnob with the fat cats.
Brian Kline
Jul 9th, 2009
Dan Onorato has the warchest, but his name does not generate excitement among Democratic activists in the southeast. Those familiar with his candidacy have one of two reactions, or both: He’s the guy who pushed through the beer tax and he’s not progressive on social issues.
Hirschhorn: 5 Democrats who could shake up Gov race… | GrassrootsPA
Jul 9th, 2009
[...] Hirschhorn: 5 Democrats who could shake up Gov race… [...]
Chris Casey (of Lehigh Co)
Jul 9th, 2009
Bob Casey will not run for Governor until 2014, or maybe 2018, after the next group of foul ups gets done. Onorato is an idiot, but will likely get the Dem nod, barring some great scandal, a la Bill Scranton in 2006. I prefer Wagner, I think he could beat Corbett. Onorato will not beat CorBett. Drink Tax, Drink Tax, Drink Tax. Prepare for that mantra to get repeated daily.
I would like to see Alyson run, it would bring a new dynamic and interest to the race.
Ryan
Jul 9th, 2009
Corbett will crush Onorato because of the drink tax and him being a socially conservative Democrat. Corbett is tame enough for SEPA moderates so this race will be about economic issues. Onorato’s record of raising taxes will hurt him.
BillyBob
Jul 9th, 2009
Tom Knox has:
1- Money (lots of it)
2- Name Recognition in Philly and is begiining to reach statewide.
3- He isn’t a political insider. He can run against the establishment and easily poke holes in Corbett’s prosecutorial mishaps.
Anonymous
Jul 9th, 2009
I like your list and your style BillyBob, keep it coming
BillyBob
Jul 9th, 2009
Chris Doherty??? WTF!!! Hell, I consider myself well versed in PA Politics and I barely know anything about the guy.
I don’t think there is any doubt that Bob Casey could win, but why in the world would he want to run? Especially since the Pa budget problems are going to extend for the next few years.