The Washington Post is proud to partner with The Washington Post in bringing our originally reported insider political news to a wide audience of decision makers and opinion leaders across the country.

Close it

Ballot challenge, spearheaded by Lentz, alleges widespread fraud in Meehan’s petitions

The nominating petitions that Republican Pat Meehan’s congressional campaign submitted to get on the May primary ballot are so rife with invalid signatures and outright fraud as to warrant keeping the former U.S. Attorney off the ballot, according to a complaint filed in Commonwealth Court.

The 15-page complaint, filed by Republican supporters of Meehan’s likely Democratic opponent Bryan Lentz, details a litany of problems with the more than 3,600 signatures collected by Meehan’s campaign, as well as with the petitions on which they were gathered. If even a fraction of the allegations prove to be true, it will cast significant doubt on Meehan’s comments last week implying that the problems were limited to signatures gathered by one just one person. Lentz’s campaign also spurred ballot challenges against both of his underdog primary opponents, E. Teresa Touey and Gail Conner, in a move that could leave him unopposed in May but could also run the risk of alienating some Democratic women (a Women for Lentz fundraiser is scheduled for Thursday evening).

It was unclear Wednesday night when court hearings for any of the challenges would take place.

The complaint, which is being handled by prominent election lawyer Clifford Levine, alleges that an examination of Meehan’s nominating petitions reveals “a wide-ranging and extensive pattern of false and forged entries, entries obtained through deception of Signers, and whole pages of outright forged signatures.” The complaint is the culmination of a several-days long effort by Lentz campaign staffers, during which they pored through Meehan’s nominating petitions and contacted people whose signatures they now believe were forged. Though Lentz cannot personally be the one challenging Meehan’s ballot position—the law requires the challenge come from a registered Republican—his campaign has made no effort to hide its fingerprints on on the complaint.

“This challenge will demonstrate that the instances of forgery and fraud in Meehan’s petitions extend far beyond what Meehan and his organization were willing to admit in their confession to the district attorney last week,” Lentz campaign manager Vincent Rongione said.

More than 2,600 signatures have to be ruled void for Meehan to be knocked off the ballot. And while the complaint involves enough signatures that it alleges to be invalid, it references evidence which will only emerge in the discovery process if the case moves forward—making it impossible to fully and independently assess the allegations at this early stage.

Meehan’s campaign did not comment directly on the complaint or its substance Wednesday, except to share with reporters a letter that he sent to Lentz about the matter. In the letter, Meehan lamented that Lentz is picking “petty fights” and playing “gotcha politics.” He dismissed the scope of the complaint’s claims, and challenged Lentz to “do better.”

“In truth, this whole part of the exercise is a charade,” Meehan wrote. “Stop hiding behind your political handlers and loyalists and stand up and make your support for this petty challenge public.”

Meehan also said this his campaign had reviewed Lent’s nominating petitions and found 550 signatures that could be challenged (Lentz’s campaign collected more than 5,000).

“But I chose not to engage in the waste of court resources that your campaign has willingly embraced,” Meehan wrote. “I believe voters deserve better.”

The complaint is nothing if not wide in scope, claiming to have evidence enough to strike 2,284 signatures simply on their individual merits. The signatures in question, according to the complaint, include ones that, among other things, were illegible; incomplete; belonging to voters not registered in the district; belong to voters not registered as Republicans; or forged entirely by someone else. It further alleges that many of the petitions on which signatures were gathered were circulated by people other than those who signed affidavits confirming they had  witnessed each signature.

All together, it appears to be the most serious ballot challenge to a major candidate this cycle. And unless it completely flops in court, even a loss would seem to have significant political upside for Lentz. Despite its competitiveness, many Democratic leaders and fundraisers are bearish on the race, seeing Meehan and the powerful Republican Party in Delaware County as exceedingly tough to beat in a year trending against the Democrats. A substantive ballot challenge could dent that perception, and energize some in the party to take at least one foot off the sidelines.

It also underscores that the Lentz campaign believes it has one of its strongest arguments against Meehan in seeking to paint him as part of the county GOP machine, a local party with a sway over local politics rivaled by few others in Pennsylvania. It’s an argument that will be especially hard to make against someone like Meehan—a man who can claim credit for putting former state Senator Vince Fumo behind bars, and who oversaw a City Hall probe that ended with guilty pleas or convictions for everyone charged.

And the complaint could also serve to put the county GOP itself “on trial,” in a manner of speaking. Some of the people the complaint targets for allegations of fraudulent signature collection include party bosses Tom Judge and John McNichol.

The complaint began to emerge about a week ago, when operatives for Lentz learned that a supporter’s wife allegedly had her signature forged on a nominating petition. They began to dig deeper, and soon, Meehan alerted the press that it had asked county District Attorney Mike Green to investigate the matter ( has yet to determine whether or not it was the Lentz campaign’s actions that directly led to Meehan learning of the problems). In his letter to Green, Meehan acknowledged that petitions circulated by one person contain signatures “that we believe are questionable.” The disclosure got Meehan’s campaign ahead of the story for a few news cycles. But Lentz staffers and volunteers worked through the weekend to review Meehan’s nominating petitions, and by the beginning of this week they were looking for a lawyer to file the complaint by the day-end deadline on Tuesday.

Levine, the lawyer handling the ballot challenge, has worked for Senator Bob Casey, and led successful the ballot challenge against a third-party candidate in the 2006 Senate race. He could not be reached for comment Wednesday.

•Also on Meehan asks D.A. to investigate his ballot petitions
D.A. investigating Meehan’s petitions also a contributor

March 17, 2010 at 11:11 pm

--Dan Hirschhorn

Tags: , , , ,


comments [70] | post a comment

  1. Virgilio Plant

    Dec 8th, 2014

    It can be nearly impossible to come across well-advised individual on this content, and yet you come across as like you fully grasp exactly what you’re preaching about! Many Thanks

  2. follow this website

    Dec 8th, 2014

    I simply want to say I am all new to weblog and honestly savored you’re web page. Very likely I’m want to bookmark your site . You certainly have outstanding well written articles. Thank you for sharing with us your web page.

  3. Carri Baldridge

    Dec 8th, 2014

    We merely need to tell you the fact that I am novice to blogging and totally admired your website. More than likely I am most likely to remember your post post . You certainly have wonderful article writing. Like it for giving out with us your internet webpage.

  4. Free Porn

    Dec 8th, 2014

    CDK Geomatics provides our clients with a complete spectrum of integrated land surveying and consulting services. Throughout our history, we’ve worked to provide our customers with a level of comfort, service and trust that exceeds their expectations.

  5. Ruthanne Olgvin

    Dec 8th, 2014

    It certainly is near unthinkable to find well-advised parties on this content, however, you look like you understand those things you’re revealing! Cheers

  6. Jenine Nocera

    Dec 8th, 2014

    Tremendously useful advice you have said, a big heads up for writing.

  7. Lonnie Lagace

    Dec 8th, 2014

    It’s the best time to make some plans for the future and it’s time to be happy. I have read this post and if I could I want to suggest you few interesting things or suggestions. Maybe you could write next articles referring to this article. I desire to read more things about it!

  8. Janeth Gruenberg

    Dec 8th, 2014

    It’s actually near unthinkable to come across well-qualified individuals on this content, fortunately you appear like you comprehend whatever you’re indicating! Gratitude

  9. Danille Burlando

    Dec 8th, 2014

    Thanks , I have recently been looking for info about this subject for ages and yours is the greatest I have discovered till now. But, what about the conclusion? Are you sure about the source?

  10. Maisie Follin

    Dec 8th, 2014

    My Partner And I really desire to inform you which I am certain inexperienced to blogging and genuinely cherished your review. Likely I am probably to bookmark your post post . You simply have superb article topic. Truly Appreciate it for telling with us your site information.

  11. Sergio Silsbee

    Dec 9th, 2014

    It is actually mostly extremely difficult to encounter well-qualified individual on this subject, however , you come across as like you fully grasp those things you’re raving about! Cheers

  12. Epifania Hunsinger

    Dec 9th, 2014

    Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon!

  13. Christen Smither

    Dec 9th, 2014

    You’ll find it practically close to impossible to find well-advised individual on this issue, and yet you come across as like you realize whatever you’re raving about! Bless You

  14. Jenelle Mccartha

    Dec 9th, 2014

    whoah this blog is magnificent i like studying your articles. Keep up the good work! You know, lots of individuals are hunting round for this information, you could aid them greatly.

  15. Tera Hyett

    Dec 9th, 2014

    I merely want to reveal to you in which I am inexperienced to wordpress blogging and utterly enjoyed your review. More than likely I am going to bookmark your article post . You absolutely have impressive article writing. Be Thankful For it for discussing with us your website post.

  16. go to this web-site

    Dec 9th, 2014

    I simply want to say I’m new to blogging and seriously enjoyed this page. Almost certainly I’m planning to bookmark your blog . You actually have very good well written articles. Regards for sharing your web-site.

  17. wyposażenie pralni

    Dec 9th, 2014

    Danke FĂĽr Dieser blog,Das Thema hat mich wirklich UnermeĂźlich gefallen. Grace in Dieses Papier habe ich viele gelernt Neue Sachen die ich ignorierte nicht.

  18. Elijah Lilienthal

    Dec 9th, 2014

    It can be mostly unattainable to find well-qualified individuals on this issue, and yet you appear like you realize exactly what you’re covering! Appreciate It

  19. Carmine Vilain

    Dec 9th, 2014

    You’ll find it almost unattainable to find well-aware people on this niche, unfortunately you seem like you know what you’re raving about! Thank You

  20. Neville Gunto

    Dec 9th, 2014

    I was recommended this web site by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my problem. You are amazing! Thanks!

Leave a Reply

- will not be published